Alaska Ranger: Everyone Who Reached a Raft Survived
On Easter Sunday 2008 the fishing vessel Alaska Ranger sank in the Bering Sea before dawn, about 120 nautical miles west of Dutch Harbor. Forty-seven people were aboard; forty-two came back. The water was 35.6 °F. We read the record: the Coast Guard's own cameras, a weather buoy, the NTSB report and the Coast Guard's Marine Board.
Chapters
- 0:00 A basket over the Munro's deck
- 1:07 Where the Alaska Ranger sank
- 1:39 Mayday at 2:46
- 1:52 Who could reach them
- 2:46 Going in reverse
- 3:56 The ship backed away from its rafts
- 4:14 A correction to episode 2
- 4:30 Buoy 46073: 35.6 °F
- 5:02 Minutes without a suit, hours with one
- 5:35 The Jayhawk arrives, 5:05
- 6:22 The rescue swimmer
- 7:32 The Munro's Dolphin
- 8:22 The Alaska Warrior and the rafts
- 8:55 Thirteen or twelve
- 10:06 Who survived, and where they were
- 10:36 Two investigations
- 11:48 What the record says
- 12:15 Next: the ship that created the rescue swimmer
Transcript
A basket over the Munro's deck 0:00
This is the flight deck of the Coast Guard cutter Munro, in the Bering Sea, on Easter Sunday, March 23rd, 2008. The helicopter is lowering a basket. A few hours earlier, the men it is bringing aboard were floating in water at thirty-five degrees Fahrenheit.
Their ship, the fishing vessel Alaska Ranger, sank before dawn, about a hundred and twenty miles west of Dutch Harbor, Alaska. Forty-seven people were aboard. Forty-two came back.
In the first episode of this series, the water was warm and the clock was the sea. In the second, a flood, the clock was the rise. This time the clock is the water itself. How long did they have? And what, in the record, decided who came back?
The record here is unusually complete. The National Transportation Safety Board wrote a report. The Coast Guard convened a Marine Board, which heard about fifty witnesses, and wrote another. And a weather buoy was floating about ninety-five miles away.
Where the Alaska Ranger sank 1:07
The Alaska Ranger was a hundred and ninety-two feet long, a catcher-processor that caught, cleaned and froze fish at sea. It went down here, at fifty-three degrees fifty-three north, a hundred and sixty-nine degrees fifty-eight west.
This is another Bering Sea fishing vessel, filmed by a Coast Guard crew six weeks later. The Alaska Ranger belonged to what the industry calls the head-and-gut fleet. By law, the safety board notes, vessels like it were exempt from Coast Guard inspection.
Mayday at 2:46 1:39
At about 2:30 in the morning, the crew found water in the rudder room, at the stern. At 2:46, the Alaska Ranger broadcast a Mayday. Everything that follows happened in the dark.
Who could reach them 1:52
Here is who could reach them. The Coast Guard air station at Kodiak was about eight hundred nautical miles away. The cutter Munro, carrying a small helicopter, was about a hundred and thirty. The Alaska Ranger's sister ship, the Alaska Warrior, was forty miles behind, with a top speed of ten knots.
And there was one more aircraft. In winter, Kodiak keeps a Jayhawk helicopter on St. Paul Island, in the Pribilofs, a hundred and ninety-seven miles from the wreck. The board notes that base normally operates from January to April. This was March.
This is a Kodiak C-130, filmed in 2010. At 2:54, the rescue center told Kodiak to launch. A C-130 and the Jayhawk on St. Paul were both in the air by about four o'clock.
Going in reverse 2:46
On the Alaska Ranger, at about 3:30, the electrical power failed. A crew member told investigators what happened next. Within minutes, he said, we were going in reverse.
The safety board traced it to the propellers. Their blade angle was held by hydraulic pumps, changed to electric pumps in 1989. With no power, the board found, the blades likely swung from ahead to astern. The engines were still running. The ship was backing up.
This is a Coast Guard camera aboard that C-130, searching later that morning. At 4:02, the Alaska Ranger told Kodiak the crew was preparing to abandon ship. The first people entered the water as early as 4:23. The ship sank shortly after 4:30, in about six thousand feet of water.
According to testimony, all forty-seven people aboard had time to put on immersion suits. The ship carried three twenty-person life rafts. This is a raft in the Bering Sea, filmed by another Kodiak crew in 2013.
The ship backed away from its rafts 3:56
But the Alaska Ranger was still going backward. It moved away from its rafts, and two of the lines holding them broke. Twelve men got into the raft still tied alongside. Ten reached one that had drifted free. Twenty-four never reached a raft.
A correction to episode 2 4:14
A correction to our last episode. We said forty-seven people went into the water. The record is more precise. Everyone put on a suit, twenty-two reached rafts, and twenty-four were in the sea with nothing but the suit.
Buoy 46073: 35.6 °F 4:30
Now the clock. The nearest weather buoy, station 46073, was about ninety-five miles to the north-west. Our reading of its record for that night: the water held at thirty-five point six degrees Fahrenheit, two degrees Celsius, hour after hour. The air was around twenty-five.
At the wreck it was worse than at the buoy. The buoy measured waves averaging eight feet. The Jayhawk pilot reported seas of twenty to twenty-five feet, and heavy snow squalls.
Minutes without a suit, hours with one 5:02
The safety board's report does the arithmetic. In calm water at about thirty-two degrees, the expected survival time without an immersion suit is thirty to ninety minutes. With a suit, two and a half to five and a half hours, depending on whether it leaks.
So the suit was the difference between minutes and hours. The first people went into the water at 4:23. The nearest helicopter was still about forty minutes out. And the Bering Sea that night was not calm water.
The Jayhawk arrives, 5:05 5:35
This is a Jayhawk's hoist camera over the Bering Sea at night, from a different rescue in 2009. The Alaska Ranger's Jayhawk reached the scene at 5:05, four hours before sunrise, under a nearly full moon.
Two months later, at a ceremony in Kodiak, Rear Admiral Gene Brooks, the commander of the Coast Guard's Alaska district, described what those crews had found. These are his words.
The rescue swimmer 6:22
At 5:21, the Jayhawk lowered its rescue swimmer, Petty Officer O'Brien Hollow, and began lifting people out, one basket at a time. The first survivor came out of the water after about fifty minutes.
The suits that kept them alive were also taking on water. The board found water inside the suits of survivors and victims alike. Twelve of the forty-four suits recovered had holes or cuts.
Lifting a man in a flooded suit means lifting the water too. During one hoist, the board says, a crew member fell about forty feet back into the sea, his suit weighed down with water. He did not survive.
By six, the Jayhawk's cabin was full. It could not lower survivors to the Alaska Warrior; the sea and the ship's layout made it unsafe. At 6:10 it turned for the Munro, now about eighty miles away.
This is the Jayhawk arriving over the Munro, filmed from the flight deck. The board's timeline puts its first arrival at 6:44. The basket comes down, the deck crew pulls the men out, and the helicopter goes back.
The Munro's Dolphin 7:32
The Munro had its own helicopter, an HH-65 Dolphin. It launched at 5:55 and reached the scene at 6:44. This is a Dolphin like it, on another cutter's deck in the Bering Sea, in 2011.
Its swimmer, Petty Officer Abram Heller, recovered three men from the water. Then, his citation says, he found two more tangled in fishing gear, worked them free, and sent them up.
Then the Dolphin had to leave. It dropped a small raft, and Heller stayed behind in the water with three survivors and that raft, waiting for the Jayhawk to come back.
The Dolphin reached the Munro with its five survivors at 8:12. The Jayhawk came back, lifted the three men and Heller, and then found the body of the Alaska Ranger's mate.
The Alaska Warrior and the rafts 8:22
And the twenty-two in the rafts? The Alaska Warrior reached them. By 10:10 that morning, it had taken all twenty-two aboard, and recovered three bodies from the water.
So the count. The Jayhawk, fifteen. The Dolphin, five. The Alaska Warrior, twenty-two. Forty-two people. The safety board called the Coast Guard's effort timely and effective, and said the winter helicopter on St. Paul aided the rescue.
Thirteen or twelve 8:55
There was one more mistake in the record, and it was a number. The Jayhawk had radioed thirteen survivors. The Munro counted twelve. At 10:12, the rescue center was told all forty-seven were accounted for.
Only when names were compared did they find a man missing: the fishmaster. The search reopened at 12:30. It was called off the next night, at 9:12. He was never found.
At that same ceremony in Kodiak, the admiral did not begin with the rescue. Before any medal was handed out, he began with the dead.
The five were the master, the mate, the chief engineer, a fish processor, and the fishmaster. Their death certificates list probable hypothermia, and for the chief engineer, drowning and hypothermia.
Who survived, and where they were 10:06
Now put the record side by side. Every one of the twenty-two who reached a raft survived. Of the twenty-four who did not, four died. They were the last people pulled from the water, after as long as five hours.
And it was not a bad suit. The board found that the four men's suits appeared properly sized, free of major damage, and worn properly. They had the right equipment. They were in the water too long.
Two investigations 10:36
Why did the ship sink? The two investigations agree on the water and disagree on the hole. The safety board blamed progressive flooding through a lack of watertight integrity, likely from losing the rudder. The Coast Guard board said the exact source is unknown.
One detail from testimony: the watertight door to the rudder room was always hooked open. And the hull that would settle the question is still down there, at about six thousand feet.
The safety board also looked at the fleet. The twenty-one vessels in the Alaska Ranger's regulatory group averaged thirty years old. The rules, it found, gave owners no way to replace an old vessel except by losing it.
And then, in the same speech, the admiral turned to the other number: the one his crews and the Alaska Warrior had brought home from that sea.
In August, in Anchorage, Abram Heller received the Distinguished Flying Cross. His citation credits him with helping to save eight of the survivors.
What the record says 11:48
So here is what the record supports. The water gave them minutes without a suit, and hours with one. A ship backing up in the dark decided who had a raft. And a helicopter parked on St. Paul for the winter decided how much of those hours they spent waiting.
The survival window in the Bering Sea that night was not one number. It was a suit, a raft, and a hundred and ninety-seven miles.
Next: the ship that created the rescue swimmer 12:15
Next: every survivor lifted out of the sea in this story was reached by a rescue swimmer. Twenty-five years earlier, the Coast Guard had none. In February 1983, the Marine Electric sank off Virginia, and thirty-one of the thirty-four aboard died. That is the next episode: the ship that created the rescue swimmer.
Description and sources
In Hurricane Sandy the clock was the sea; in Harvey it was the rise. In the Bering Sea it was the water itself. Our reading of NDBC buoy 46073, about 95 nautical miles from the wreck: 35.6 °F all night, air around 25 °F. The NTSB gives the arithmetic: in calm water at about 32 °F, 30 to 90 minutes without an immersion suit, 2.5 to 5.5 hours with one. All 47 aboard had time to put on a suit. But after the power failed at about 3:30, the ship went backward, the propellers likely swung to astern pitch, and it moved away from its own life rafts. Twelve got into the raft still tied alongside, ten reached one that drifted free, twenty-four were in the sea with only the suit. A Jayhawk based on St. Paul Island for the winter, 197 miles away, arrived at 5:05; the cutter Munro's Dolphin at 6:44; the sister ship Alaska Warrior took the 22 from the rafts. Count: 15, 5 and 22. Every one of the 22 who reached a raft survived; four of the 24 who did not died, after as long as five hours in the water, in suits the board found properly sized and worn. A fifth man, the fishmaster, was never found, after a miscount of 13 for 12 told the rescue center everyone was accounted for.
PRIMARY SOURCES
- National Transportation Safety Board (2009). Sinking of U.S. Fishing Vessel Alaska Ranger, Bering Sea, March 23, 2008. Marine Accident Report NTSB/MAR-09/05. https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/MAR0905.pdf
- U.S. Coast Guard (2010, released Jan 2011). Report of Investigation into the circumstances surrounding the sinking of the F/V Alaska Ranger. Archived: https://web.archive.org/web/20160304134755id_/http://www.uscg.mil/hq/cg5/cg545/docs/boards/AlaskaRanger.pdf
- gCaptain (13 Jan 2011). Coast Guard releases report on sinking of Alaska Ranger: https://gcaptain.com/coast-guard-releases-report-sinking/
- NOAA National Data Buoy Center, station 46073 (Southeast Bering Sea), historical standard meteorological data, 2008: https://www.ndbc.noaa.gov/station_page.php?station=46073
- Valor (Military Times). Distinguished Flying Cross citation, AST Abram A. Heller, USCG: https://valor.militarytimes.com/?p=350591
- KMXT (15 May 2008). Coast Guard crews honored: https://archive.kmxt.org/2008/05/coast-guard-crews-honored/
- Seapower Magazine (6 May 2019). Rescue swimmer program starts after tragedy at sea: https://seapowermagazine.org/rescue-swimmer-program-starts-after-tragedy-at-sea/
Survival Window reads a rescue through the record it left: the crews' own cameras, the instruments nearby, and the reports listed above.
About the material. Video: U.S. Coast Guard (Coast Guard Atlantic Area and Public Affairs Detachment Kodiak, including PA3 Richard Brahm; Air Station Kodiak; PA1 Kurt Fredrickson, PA1 Sara Francis, PO3 Charly Hengen, PO1 William Colclough; Coast Guard Arctic), released through DVIDS, public domain. Footage from other Kodiak missions is identified as such in the narration. The words of Rear Admiral Gene Brooks are from the Coast Guard's own video of the Kodiak awards ceremony, 15 May 2008. The buoy series is our own reading of NDBC data. Every diagram is drawn in code from the sources listed. Nothing in this video is AI-generated imagery.
The appearance of U.S. Department of Defense or U.S. Coast Guard visual information does not imply or constitute endorsement. This channel is independent and not affiliated with the U.S. Coast Guard.