The Mediterranean Was a Desert Two Kilometres Below Sea Level
In 1970 a drilling ship in the middle of the Mediterranean pulled up rock salt from under three kilometres of water. Rock salt only forms when seawater evaporates away. The sea you know is younger than the rock underneath it, and the way it came back is the part nobody teaches.
Chapters
- 0:00 Rock salt, from the floor of an open sea
- 0:27 The rock underneath is a desert
- 0:44 The sea in the middle of the land
- 1:04 The rock was never hidden
- 1:37 What the drill went through
- 2:04 1973: seas do not empty
- 2:27 Close the strait and the basin goes down
- 2:53 Why the door closed
- 3:25 A million cubic kilometres of salt
- 3:47 The lowest dry land there has ever been
- 4:11 The Nile canyon under Cairo
- 4:38 Six hundred thousand years
- 5:02 How anyone knows it was 5.96
- 5:24 The sediment is a calendar
- 5:57 The Atlantic finds the sill
- 6:21 A thousand times the Amazon
- 6:41 The flood dug its own doorway
- 7:02 It did not stop at Sardinia
- 7:31 A boundary you can put your hand on
- 7:56 Every easy version was wrong
- 8:28 What the rock kept instead
Transcript
Rock salt, from the floor of an open sea 0:00
In the summer of nineteen seventy, a drilling ship called the Glomar Challenger was working in the middle of the Mediterranean, with three kilometres of water underneath it. Below the soft deep sea mud, the bit went into gypsum. Then anhydrite. Then rock salt, and a lot of it. Those minerals form when seawater evaporates away. They were sitting on the floor of an open sea.
The rock underneath is a desert 0:27
The Mediterranean is probably the most photographed sea on Earth. Four thousand years of ships, coastlines, cities. It looks permanent. The water is about five million years old. The rock underneath it is a desert.
The sea in the middle of the land 0:44
Everyone carries the same picture of this sea. Ancient, continuous, the cradle of everything that came after. It is where the word Mediterranean comes from: the sea in the middle of the land. A fixed thing that history happened around. That is the part the rock does not agree with.
The rock was never hidden 1:04
And here is what makes the argument stranger. The rock was never hidden. On Sicily there are hills of banded gypsum you can walk up to, and they were mapped in the eighteen hundreds. In eighteen sixty seven the whole age was named after the city of Messina, from fossils found between those gypsum beds. The evaporites had been in plain sight for a hundred and three years before that ship sailed. What nobody had was the idea that the same layer ran out under three kilometres of water.
What the drill went through 1:37
Read the core from the bottom up and it tells you how much water was there, layer by layer. It starts with fine marine mud, the kind that only settles in deep, open water. Then gypsum, which needs a shrinking, salty pool. Then rock salt on a scale that is hard to picture. Then brackish beds, almost a lake. And then, sharply, deep sea mud again.
1973: seas do not empty 2:04
In March of nineteen seventy three, Kenneth Hsu, William Ryan and Maria Bianca Cita published what the cores meant, in Nature. The title was blunt: late Miocene desiccation of the Mediterranean. The reaction was not agreement. The objection was simple, and it was reasonable. Seas do not empty.
Close the strait and the basin goes down 2:27
But the arithmetic of this particular sea only runs one way. The Mediterranean loses far more water to evaporation than its rivers and its rain put back. The difference is made up by the Atlantic, flowing in through the strait at Gibraltar. That flow is not a detail. It is the only reason there is a sea here. Close the strait, and the basin starts going down.
Why the door closed 2:53
So what closed it. Africa has been pushing north into Eurasia for tens of millions of years, and it has not stopped. Before the Strait of Gibraltar existed there were two other doorways: the Betic corridor, through what is now southern Spain, and the Rifian corridor, through what is now Morocco. The collision lifted both of them out of the water. A sea two thousand five hundred kilometres long was shut off by a few hundred metres of uplift, in two narrow places.
A million cubic kilometres of salt 3:25
By one estimate, the water in the basin, some three point seven million cubic kilometres of it, would be gone in a little over a thousand years. What it left behind is the part that is hard to argue with. More than a million cubic kilometres of salt. Fifty times the salt dissolved in the entire Mediterranean today.
The lowest dry land there has ever been 3:47
So picture what was actually down there. A basin floor lying three to five kilometres below the level of the ocean outside it. Salt flats, brine lakes at the lowest points, and rock walls kilometres high all around. Not a beach. Not a lagoon. This is the lowest dry land the planet has ever had.
The Nile canyon under Cairo 4:11
The rivers kept coming. They had to reach the sea, and the sea was now kilometres further down. So they cut. The Nile carved a canyon into its own bed. Two hundred metres below sea level at Aswan. Two and a half kilometres below sea level near Cairo. That canyon is still there, filled in with sediment. Cairo is built on top of it.
Six hundred thousand years 4:38
This is not a moment. It is a period. The basin was cut off from about five point nine six million years ago, and the crisis ends at five point three three. Six hundred thousand years with no sea in the Mediterranean at all. Long enough that if you had been standing on that salt floor, nothing about it would have felt temporary.
How anyone knows it was 5.96 5:02
You should ask how anyone knows it was five point nine six, and not six point one. The answer is that the rock counts. The marls below the evaporites are not uniform. They are stacked in rhythmic couplets, pale and dark, over and over. Each couplet is one turn of a cycle in the Earth's orbit.
The sediment is a calendar 5:24
And orbital cycles are calculable. We know when each one happened, the same way we know when an eclipse happened. So you count the couplets down from a fixed point, and the sediment stops being a pile of mud and becomes a calendar. That is how Krijgsman and colleagues put the onset at five point nine six million years ago, give or take twenty thousand. And the same date turns up on both sides of the basin, two thousand kilometres apart. Whatever closed the door, it closed everywhere at once.
The Atlantic finds the sill 5:57
And then the Atlantic came back. Not as a rising tide. Not over centuries. Water found a low point in the rock at Gibraltar and started through, and moving water cuts. The more it cut, the more came through, and the more came through, the faster it cut. Once that starts, there is nothing to stop it.
A thousand times the Amazon 6:21
The modelling puts the peak discharge at up to a hundred million cubic metres per second. Around a thousand times the Amazon. More than ninety percent of the water went in somewhere between a few months and two years. Inside the basin, the sea level was climbing more than ten metres a day.
The flood dug its own doorway 6:41
A flow that size does not fit through a channel. It makes one. About a thousand cubic kilometres of rock were stripped out of the strait. The water fell more than a thousand metres on its way in, moving at over forty metres a second. The flood dug its own doorway, and we are still sailing through it.
It did not stop at Sardinia 7:02
For a long time this was a western story. The water comes through Gibraltar and fills the basin nearest to it. Then the seafloor east of Sicily was mapped properly. There is an erosion surface down there, buried under later sediment, cut across the ridge that separates the western Mediterranean from the eastern one. Same event, hundreds of kilometres further on. The water went over the sill and kept going.
A boundary you can put your hand on 7:31
You can go and stand on the end of this. On the south coast of Sicily, at Eraclea Minoa, there is a cliff where white marine marl sits directly on the deposits of the crisis. That contact is the formal base of the Zanclean, and of the Pliocene: five point three three two million years ago, give or take five thousand. It is a boundary you can put your hand on.
Every easy version was wrong 7:56
There is a pattern worth naming before we leave. Every version of this that was easy to believe turned out to be the wrong one. An old sea that was always there. A shallow lagoon that dried out a little. A slow refill over centuries. Each of those is a reasonable thing to assume. Each one was replaced by something the rock said instead. The rock is not more imaginative than we are. It is just not trying to make the story comfortable.
What the rock kept instead 8:28
None of this is in the tidy version. The tidy version has an old sea that was always there. The rock kept the salt, the canyon and the contact instead. Next time, something bigger, and stranger. The air you are breathing right now was the worst contamination event in the history of this planet. And the evidence is not the banded iron everyone shows you. It is a sulphur signature that simply stops existing, about two point three billion years ago.
Description and sources
Between about 5.96 and 5.33 million years ago the Mediterranean was cut off from the Atlantic and evaporated almost completely. What was left was a basin floor three to five kilometres below the level of the ocean outside it — the lowest dry land the planet has ever had — with salt flats, brine lakes and rock walls kilometres high.
The evidence is an object you can go and check. On DSDP Leg 13, the Glomar Challenger drilled gypsum, anhydrite and over a kilometre of halite out of the abyssal plain. Hsü, Ryan and Cita published what it meant in Nature in March 1973, and the reaction was not agreement: seas do not empty.
Then the Atlantic came back. Modelling puts the peak discharge at up to a hundred million cubic metres per second — around a thousand times the Amazon — with more than ninety per cent of the water transferred in somewhere between a few months and two years. The flood stripped roughly a thousand cubic kilometres of rock out of the strait and dug the doorway ships still use.
The dates are not guesses. The marls below the evaporites are stacked in rhythmic couplets paced by the Earth's orbit, and orbital cycles can be calculated backwards. Count the couplets and the sediment becomes a calendar: the onset lands at 5.96 million years ago, give or take twenty thousand, and the same date turns up on both sides of the basin, two thousand kilometres apart.
The end of it has a formal address. At Eraclea Minoa on the south coast of Sicily, white marine marl sits directly on the deposits of the crisis. That contact is the base of the Zanclean and of the Pliocene: 5.332 million years ago.
PRINT-READY, FROM THIS CHANNEL
The Deep Time Record, Vol. 01 — the cores, the curves and the clocks
https://therepository.gumroad.com/l/deep-time-record
PRIMARY SOURCES
- Hsü, K. J., Ryan, W. B. F., and Cita, M. B. — Late Miocene desiccation of the Mediterranean. Nature 242, 240-244, 1973. https://www.nature.com/articles/242240a0
- Hsü, K. J., Cita, M. B., and Ryan, W. B. F. — The Origin of the Mediterranean Evaporite. Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Project, vol. 13, chapter 43, 1973. https://deepseadrilling.org/13/volume/dsdp13pt2_43.pdf
- Chumakov, I. S. — Pliocene and Pleistocene Deposits of the Nile Valley in Nubia and Upper Egypt. Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Project, vol. 13, chapter 44.3, 1973. https://deepseadrilling.org/13/volume/dsdp13pt2_44_3.pdf
- Krijgsman, W., Hilgen, F. J., Raffi, I., Sierro, F. J., and Wilson, D. S. — Chronology, causes and progression of the Messinian salinity crisis. Nature 400, 652-655, 1999. https://www.nature.com/articles/23231
- Garcia-Castellanos, D. and Villasenor, A. — Messinian salinity crisis regulated by competing tectonics and erosion at the Gibraltar arc. Nature 475, 462-466, 2011. https://www.nature.com/articles/nature10651
- Garcia-Castellanos, D., Estrada, F., Jiménez-Munt, I., Gorini, C., Fernàndez, M., Vergés, J., and De Vicente, R. — Catastrophic flood of the Mediterranean after the Messinian salinity crisis. Nature 462, 778-781, 2009. https://www.nature.com/articles/nature08555
- Micallef, A. et al. — Evidence of the Zanclean megaflood in the eastern Mediterranean Basin. Scientific Reports 8, 1078, 2018. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-19446-3
The 21 generated plates were made for this channel with SDXL 1.0. No person is depicted in any of them.
Deep Time Archives rebuilds the pre-human Earth from the physical record — drill cores, outcrops, golden spikes. Every episode starts from an object you can go and check, and the sources are listed above.
The landscapes in this video are painted illustrations made for the channel. They are reconstructions, not photographs: nobody photographed a dry Mediterranean. The stratigraphic column, the time ruler and the ratio charts are drawn from the figures in the sources listed above.